App Review

RSS for tag

App review is the process of evaluating apps and app updates submitted to the App Store to ensure they are reliable, perform as expected, and follow Apple guidelines.

Posts under App Review tag

200 Posts

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
0
0
8.2k
Mar ’25
Three 4.3(a) rejections, no comparison app named, reviewer demo account never signed in, live web app community. What can I do?
Looking for experience from developers whose "4.3(a) Design - Spam" rejection was eventually explained or overturned. My situation: Our developer account has no other apps. This app is our own code, design and data. Nobody on the team is on any other developer account. The app is the iOS client of a web service that has been live since 2025 with an active community of a few thousand registered users. The same app got recently published on Google Play. The app allows logged-out browsing, though many features require a free account. Sign in with Apple, OAuth and email/password are all supported. Since this is largely a community app, we built proper moderation and privacy features: automated Amazon Rekognition screening and human moderation of all user-submitted media before it is published, plus block and report for users and content. The app is in the collecting / tracking hobby and covers niche material that mainstream apps do not carry. For several of the franchises we carry we are not aware of any App Store app at all. First version: rejected 4.3(a). We rewrote the subtitle, keywords and description. Second review: the same boilerplate 4.3(a) text, no explanation. Appealed to the App Review Board: upheld, no app named, same generic response. Second version (about a month later) a genuinely different release with new released: focus shifted to community features, messaging, full iPad support with proper design, new screenshots. We also attached a video walkthrough of the features no other app covers and gave the reviewer detailed instructions on where to find them and why they matter to users. Result: the same 4.3(a) text after about 15 days in review, again no app named. Our server records show the demo account we provided in App Review Information was never signed into during the second review (no auth event, no SDK session). Everything the review notes point to is behind sign-in. The codebase is Expo. The only stock pieces are the RevenueCat paywall and the social login buttons. Everything else is ours, including a large backend and data pipeline. What I would love to know from others who faced this: when your 4.3(a) was finally resolved, what was the actual cause? What did the journey look like? Anything concrete would help me know where to look.
2
0
93
1h
New app "Waiting for Review" for 6 days after replying to a 5.1.1(v) rejection, expedite accepted
Our first iOS release, Talea: Music Lessons (Apple ID 6822433276), was rejected on 11 November under Guideline 5.1.1(v). We replied in App Store Connect the same day, explaining why the information is needed for the app's age rules, and resubmitted the same build. The submission has been "Waiting for Review" since 11 November and our reply has had no answer. An expedited review request was accepted on 17 November. The app has been live on Google Play since 2 November, and teachers and students are waiting for the iOS version. Could someone from App Review look at submission a25aeb0c-7a67-446a-a195-a3694a8e9ede, or tell us if anything more is needed from our side? Thank you.
0
0
36
2h
Eternal waiting for review problem
Hi everyone. I'm developer, who works just with iOS for the last 4 years, and am a part of Apple ecosystem from 2012, work with swift (no cross-platform like unity etc.) During last month I get such a problem - time of waiting for review for my new app is geting longer and longer. This is time chronology: Nov 4, 2026 at 8:55 PM - Waiting for Review Nov 13, 2026 at 8:52 PM - In Review Nov 13, 2026 at 8:52 PM - Rejected (as you can see, there is auto-rejection even with no app review), with autogenerate message, after my reply I still wait for real review Nov 13, 2026 at 9:27 PM - Waiting for Review So, at the moment it's around 2 weeks from the start of waiting/review process (even though Apple tell us that 90% of reviews go withing 48 hours). No answer for all my letters, no reaction for Expredited Review ticket. So, Apple, sorry for such a direct question, but, what's going wrong with all your processes now? P.S.: Dear developers, if you have the same problem, please, try to support this ticket, as we can get more replies, I do hope - we can get Apple attention faster.
3
1
102
2h
Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6: Publishing separate apps for multiple companies under one or separate developer accounts
Hello everyone, I’m developing a work management app using React Native/Expo for multiple companies. The apps share a common codebase and similar core functionality, but each company has its own app name, logo, bundle ID, and company-specific data. Each company wants a separate app publicly available on the App Store so users can search for and download it. Private distribution through Custom Apps or a single shared app with a company selector would not meet their requirements. I’d like to understand how App Review Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6 apply to these two scenarios: 1. All apps published under one organization’s developer account Our company would develop and publish all client apps under our own Apple Developer Program organization account. Is there a compliant way to support this model? What requirements would each app need to meet? 2. Each app published under the client company’s own developer account Each client company would enroll in the Apple Developer Program and publish its app under its own organization account, while our team handles development and assists with submission. Could these apps still be rejected under Guideline 4.3(a) because they share a codebase and similar functionality? For both scenarios, I’d appreciate clarification on the following: What differences in functionality, content, or business workflows would help establish each app as a distinct product? How does Guideline 4.2.6 apply to this shared-platform model? What supporting documentation should we provide, such as development contracts or letters of authorization? How should we explain the business need for separate apps in App Review Notes? Has anyone successfully implemented a similar model? I’m looking for a compliant, sustainable approach, rather than a workaround to the review guidelines. Thank you for your advice and experience.
1
0
132
2h
app for a web-based business service covered by 3.1.3(f)?
Hi all, My iOS app has been rejected several times under Guidelines 3.1.1 and 3.1.3(c), and I'd appreciate input from anyone who has dealt with something similar. The app is a free app for booking appointments with local service businesses (salons, barbers, etc.). Customers use it for free and can pay an optional deposit directly to a business for a real-world service. Business owners use the same app to manage their calendar and clients. The paid part: Business owners buy a subscription to our web-based management service only on our website. The app has no In-App Purchase, no pricing, and no button or link to purchase or manage a subscription, inside or outside the app. The only related screen is a read-only "Subscription Status: Active" label. The rejection: The reviewer says the app offers enterprise services sold to organizations that are also available to single users, so In-App Purchase is required under 3.1.3(c). My question: We are not relying on 3.1.3(c). Our understanding is that a free, stand-alone app that gives access to a paid web service, with no purchase flow and no call to action to buy, is covered by 3.1.3(f). Is that reading correct even when the service is also available to solo business owners? I've replied in App Store Connect and filed an appeal with the App Review Board. If anyone has had a similar case resolved, I'd be glad to hear what helped. Thanks!
1
0
53
5h
My game stuck "Waiting for review" practically since Oct 23
I've been working on www.riotcontrolgame.com for almost 9 months before submitting it to the App store, in parallel of Steam and Android. From my experience I was sure it will be approved on Apple first - but it's already approved in all other platforms and I'm just waiting for Apple so I can finally announce and release it properly. I don't know what's the hold up, I feel utterly ignored. The game was at first rejected as "4.3 Spam" which I answered in detail for every concern Apple app review raised. It's an original and unique game that was developed across many months, with many testers, and includes an App clip and search videos. This is a legit and unique tower defense game that is no spam no matter how you look at it. I feel ignored and time goes by, weeks upon weeks with 0 response or care from Apple, which is the only place I'm literally paying 100$ a year to be a developer. I'm getting more attention from Android and Steam, and much faster responsiveness compared. I love Apple, and I want to continue releasing apps and games to the App Store. Please, if there's anyone who can run some kind of a total account review and contact me (in any media possible), I will highly appreciate it.
0
0
64
7h
Account suspended under DPLA 14.8(a) – compliance documents provided over a week ago
My Individual Developer account (Team ID: SU8NVE3Z6C) has been suspended due to an automated compliance check regarding digital assets, citing Sections 14.8(a) and 2.8 of the DPLA. I have a clean 13-year track record on the App Store. On September 23, immediately after receiving the automated notice, I submitted all requested documentary evidence directly to provider_review. I provided my official residence documents and description of my apps. They do not involve custody, exchange, trading, or transmission of digital assets, nor do they violate any applicable laws. It has now been over a week since I submitted the full documentation. My entire portfolio of apps remains removed from the App Store. This prolonged downtime is causing severe ongoing financial loss and severely disrupting the experience for my active subscribers. Could an Apple Community Specialist or a senior support engineer please help escalate this review? I have provided everything asked of me and urgently need my account access restored. Thank you in advance for your assistance.
9
7
1.2k
8h
Resubmission in Waiting for Review since 1 November
App: Clube de Campo de São Paulo (Apple ID 6827749386), iOS 1.1 (1) Submission ID: b0f93dd1-d7eb-4ced-9390-89522733fdd4 This is a new app. It was rejected on 30 October under guideline 2.5.4. We replied on 1 November with an explanation and a screen recording, and resubmitted the same day. It has been in Waiting for Review since then, and our expedited review request has had no response. We have also opened Developer Support case 30000010412347. Could someone from App Review check whether anything is blocking this submission?
2
0
117
8h
First app stuck in "Waiting for Review" since November 7, support case unanswered
Hello, My first app has been in "Waiting for Review" for 10 days without moving, and I would appreciate it if someone from App Review could check whether anything is holding it. App: FindDish (Apple ID 6818187210), iOS Version 1.0, build 261107.1004 Submission ID: 952c8d73-8ddf-478a-98b2-3aefc343c77a Submitted: November 7, 2026, 10:53 UTC Developer Support case: 30000013180228 (opened November 12; so far only the automatic acknowledgement) This is the first submission from a new individual developer account. The submission has not been cancelled or resubmitted. There are no messages in App Store Connect and no information requests. The agreements are accepted, App Privacy is published, and the trader information for the Digital Services Act was submitted on November 7 and still shows as being verified. Is there anything missing on my side, for example the trader verification, that keeps the app from entering review? If something else is needed I will provide it right away. Thank you.
0
0
29
8h
Case ID: 103016369752 - App stuck in Process for Distribution
Hi, my app has beens stuck in Process for Distribution for over 2 weeks. I have tried to contact the developement team which escalated it to the review team but now it has gone silent for over a week. Does anyone know how to contact the correct team to resolve this issue? It is very frustratiing because I cannot even reject the update and restart the review process. It is in limbo. Please help! Case ID: 103016369752
0
0
17
9h
Expedited review was approved, but app stuck in Waiting for Review since Nov 13
Hello App Review Team, I’m writing to ask for your help checking my app submission. I submitted my app for review on November 13. It has now been over 96 hours (4 full days). I previously emailed the App Review team to request expedited review, and my expedited review request was formally approved. The reply confirmed my app would be reviewed as soon as possible. However, up to this point, I still see no movement on my app’s review status. The build remains stuck in Waiting for Review with no pending messages or additional requests inside App Store Connect. Based on the current progress, even with the approved expedited review, my app is taking longer than a standard non-expedited submission. I am trying to understand the reason for this. Could you please look into this delay and advise what might be causing it? Please let me know what actions I need to take on my end.submission ID:78b8dd94-fd4c-4951-959b-4fdb57a659d7 I appreciate your support.
0
0
66
11h
DishNear: Homemade Food — "Waiting for Review" 14 days after resubmission (Apple ID 6795711801)
Our first app, DishNear: Homemade Food (iOS 1.0.0, build 8, Australia only), was rejected on 2 Nov 2026. We answered both points (EULA link and IAP price confirmation) and resubmitted on 3 Nov 2026. It has been Waiting for Review since. We sent status inquiries on 9 Nov (case 30000009951816) and 16 Nov, with no reply. Agreements, tax and banking are all active, and there are no open messages in App Store Connect. Could someone from App Review confirm the submission is queued correctly and whether anything is needed from us? Thank you.
0
0
179
15h
Waiting for Review since Nov 13 after answering Guideline 2.1(b), expedite approved (App ID 6830445332)
Hello App Review team, Our app Nova Owner (Apple ID 6830445332, submission ID b14521ae-ffd5-4612-b96e-adf082ed39f6, version 1.0.0 (3)) has been Waiting for Review since November 13 after we answered a Guideline 2.1(b) business model question. Timeline (UTC): Nov 4: first submission. Nov 5: Guideline 2.1 information request, answered with a screen recording. Nov 12: expedited review approved. Nov 13: Guideline 2.1(b) business model question. We answered all six questions in App Store Connect at 05:56 and resubmitted the same build at 06:01. Our backend logs show a reviewer session from Apple's network on Nov 13, 06:05–06:08, covering every tab of the demo account. There has been no reviewer sign-in or app activity since then, and no new message in App Store Connect. Business model: Nova Owner is a free companion app for homeowners who have an offline property management agreement with our company for physical services at their home. Fees are settled on the owner's monthly statement outside the app. The app sells and unlocks no digital content, subscriptions or features, and has no payment of any kind. We need to launch to our existing clients this month. Could someone please check whether the submission is waiting on anything from us? Thank you.
0
0
148
16h
Is Apple Music artwork allowed in a music discovery app without playback?
Hi Apple Developer Community, I'm developing an iOS app focused on music discovery and social interaction. Users can share songs with people nearby, and I'd like to use the Apple Music API to retrieve song metadata and album artwork. The artwork would appear on map markers, shared song cards, and user music profiles. The app is not primarily a music player, and users would be able to open songs in Apple Music. I'd like to clarify: Is this use of Apple Music metadata and album artwork permitted under the MusicKit / Apple Music API terms, even without in-app music playback? Would displaying artwork in these social discovery contexts require additional licensing or permission? If additional permission is needed, which official Apple team or licensing channel should I contact? I want to ensure the app complies with Apple's terms before release. Thank you for your guidance!
0
0
151
16h
Unbelievable: 2 App Store rejections, ZERO uses of our app's main feature. What would you do - appeal or resubmit?
I'm genuinely at a loss with Apple's App Review process. Our backend records show that across BOTH reviews, Apple's reviewers did not complete a SINGLE use of our app's core functionality. Not once. ZERO completed generations. For the latest review, our logs confirm Apple successfully logged in, but recorded ZERO generation requests and ZERO credits consumed. This isn't some minor feature. It's the entire foundation of our app. Our app fundamentally changes and becomes personalised as it's used. Without completing that process, you're essentially judging an incomplete product. Submission ID: 6a126514-9bb6-4d91-923c-bf29aacb1b68 Here's why this is so frustrating. We spent months deliberately building an app that offers functionality and a user experience fundamentally different from existing competitors. This wasn't another copycat app - avoiding that was central to its design from day one. We explained these differences extensively in our App Review notes. Yet Apple has rejected us TWICE under Guideline 4.3(b) — Design Spam. We even provided a narrated walkthrough demonstrating exactly what makes our app unique. Our video analytics show ZERO views. So we're being rejected for supposedly lacking originality, despite neither review producing a completed use of our main feature and no recorded views of our demonstration. After both rejections, we've received nothing but generic responses telling us to improve the app, without identifying a single specific problem. How are independent developers supposed to fix something when Apple won't explain what's wrong? We've now filed a formal appeal, which could take a month, with no visible queue position, progress updates or estimated timeframe. Meanwhile, we've already missed multiple planned marketing opportunities, and waiting could mean missing even more. We're not asking for guaranteed approval. We're asking for a fair review of what we've actually built. Has anyone else experienced this? What would you do? Wait for the appeal, hoping the App Review Board properly evaluates the app, even if it takes another month and we miss more deadlines? Withdraw the appeal and resubmit, hoping for a different reviewer, but risking another rejection without proper testing and further warnings against our developer account? I'd genuinely appreciate advice from anyone who's experienced something similar, especially those who've successfully appealed a 4.3(b) rejection. At this point, I genuinely don't know whether this is a reviewer misunderstanding, an automated rejection process, or something else entirely. But how can Apple determine that an app lacks originality when its defining functionality hasn't even been tested?
18
1
998
17h
App stuck "In Review" for 12 days after resubmission (Case 103001645719)
Hello, Our app has been in "In Review" status since October 25, 2026 — 12 days now, with no messages or requests from App Review. App: Ryla: Photo Looks & Filters (Apple ID 6821447421) Submission ID: bbe1d65e-6429-4c33-9a25-7c2128f6c8a8 Items: version 1.0 (build 10), two auto-renewable subscriptions, a subscription group and three consumable in-app purchases Developer Support case: 103001645719 Timeline: Oct 12: first submission Oct 25: rejected under Guideline 1.1 (screenshots); we replaced the flagged screenshots and previews and resubmitted the same day Oct 25 → today: "In Review", no further updates We have also requested an expedited review and replied to our Developer Support case. Agreements, tax and banking are all active, and there are no unanswered messages in App Store Connect. Could someone from App Review please check whether this submission is stuck? We're happy to provide a demo video, test details or anything else needed right away. Thank you.
3
0
149
17h
App Stuck In Review Since October 26, 2026 — No Updates Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello, I'm reaching out regarding an ongoing issue with an iOS application that has been stuck in the "In Review" status since October 26, 2026. As of today, November 13, the application has been in review for 18 days without any updates, rejection notices, requests for additional information, or communication explaining the delay. I've published multiple applications through the App Store before, and while I understand that review times can vary, I've never experienced anything remotely close to this. I've reached out to Apple Developer Support multiple times, sent approximately five emails, and even spent nearly three hours on hold trying to speak with someone who could provide some information. I've also submitted an expedited review request, which unfortunately hasn't resulted in any progress either. I even spoke with a support representative who mentioned that they would try to push the issue forward, but despite all these attempts, I still haven't received any meaningful updates or explanations. This delay has significantly affected my business, and it's incredibly frustrating to have an application sitting in review for this long without knowing what's happening or whether anything is actually being done. I completely understand that certain applications might require additional review time, and I have no issue with that. However, I would at least expect some form of communication, especially after nearly three weeks and multiple attempts to contact support. At this point, I'm genuinely concerned that the application might be stuck in Apple's review system or that something has gone wrong internally. Has anyone experienced a similar situation where an application remained specifically in "In Review" for this long? Is there any way to reach someone directly from the App Review team or escalate this beyond the standard support channels? I've already tried requesting an expedited review without success, so I'm unsure what other options are available. I'd appreciate any guidance or assistance, especially from someone at Apple who might be able to look into this. Thank you.
3
0
225
17h
Approved Expedited Review Stuck in "Waiting for Review" for 90+ Hours — App ID 6828609335
App: Drip Rides (App ID 6828609335), version 1.0.13 — a new app submission made on October 30, 2026. It has been in "Waiting for Review" since submission and has never moved to "In Review." An expedited review was requested for a timed launch and approved on Sunday, November 1, but the status has not changed since — over 90 hours in "Waiting for Review" in total. We announced a November 2 launch and have missed it. Developer Support case: 103017689548 App Review inquiry case: 30000003909762 (filed today, November 3) Could someone please check whether the expedited review is properly attached to this submission and escalate it to the App Review team for manual assignment? Thank you. — Eric, Drip Rides
3
0
182
17h
App Stuck in Review for Over a Month – Already Published on Google Play with Strong User Interest
Hello Apple App Review Team, I am an independent game developer, and my game has been stuck in the App Review process for approximately one month without a final decision. Submission ID: e1dfbdc4-ed91-4e02-acf5-1de15461d895 My application has been awaiting review for an unusually long period. After several weeks without progress, I canceled the previous submission and submitted it again, hoping to resolve the delay. Unfortunately, the latest submission is still in "Waiting for Review", with no further updates or explanation. I would also like to highlight that my game is already published on Google Play, where it has attracted significant user interest and exceeded 10,000 downloads. Google Play link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.alpsoft.kus The game is actively available to Android users, and I am eager to make it available to iOS users as well. As an independent developer, I have invested considerable time and effort into creating and improving this game. The prolonged review delay is affecting my ability to reach new players and expand to another platform. I fully understand that Apple needs to carefully review applications before publication. However, I would sincerely appreciate assistance in understanding why my submission has remained pending for so long. Could an Apple App Review representative please: Investigate the reason for this unusually long delay. Confirm whether anything is preventing my application from entering active review. Escalate my submission to the appropriate team. Provide an update or guidance on any further steps required. I am not requesting automatic approval or special treatment. I simply hope my game can receive a fair and timely review. Thank you for your time and assistance. I would greatly appreciate any help in resolving this situation. Best regards, Independent Game Developer
2
0
383
17h
developer information updating in process for more than 30 days?
hi, I have updated my developer information months ago, it is almost before 30 days, I found that I could not submit any updates or new app to AppStore as it says "Note: Your developer information update is in process.". I know it will take some time, as the document states it is about 1 or 2 weeks, however, it is now more than 30 days passed, it is still in process. I am a little worried about what happened on this process? I want to get contact with the right Apple employee, so that I could know what happened on it. There're some updates and bug fixes I could not wait for more time, so if anyone know how to get it solved, it will be very appreciated!
1
0
656
21h
Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
8.2k
Activity
Mar ’25
Three 4.3(a) rejections, no comparison app named, reviewer demo account never signed in, live web app community. What can I do?
Looking for experience from developers whose "4.3(a) Design - Spam" rejection was eventually explained or overturned. My situation: Our developer account has no other apps. This app is our own code, design and data. Nobody on the team is on any other developer account. The app is the iOS client of a web service that has been live since 2025 with an active community of a few thousand registered users. The same app got recently published on Google Play. The app allows logged-out browsing, though many features require a free account. Sign in with Apple, OAuth and email/password are all supported. Since this is largely a community app, we built proper moderation and privacy features: automated Amazon Rekognition screening and human moderation of all user-submitted media before it is published, plus block and report for users and content. The app is in the collecting / tracking hobby and covers niche material that mainstream apps do not carry. For several of the franchises we carry we are not aware of any App Store app at all. First version: rejected 4.3(a). We rewrote the subtitle, keywords and description. Second review: the same boilerplate 4.3(a) text, no explanation. Appealed to the App Review Board: upheld, no app named, same generic response. Second version (about a month later) a genuinely different release with new released: focus shifted to community features, messaging, full iPad support with proper design, new screenshots. We also attached a video walkthrough of the features no other app covers and gave the reviewer detailed instructions on where to find them and why they matter to users. Result: the same 4.3(a) text after about 15 days in review, again no app named. Our server records show the demo account we provided in App Review Information was never signed into during the second review (no auth event, no SDK session). Everything the review notes point to is behind sign-in. The codebase is Expo. The only stock pieces are the RevenueCat paywall and the social login buttons. Everything else is ours, including a large backend and data pipeline. What I would love to know from others who faced this: when your 4.3(a) was finally resolved, what was the actual cause? What did the journey look like? Anything concrete would help me know where to look.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
93
Activity
1h
New app "Waiting for Review" for 6 days after replying to a 5.1.1(v) rejection, expedite accepted
Our first iOS release, Talea: Music Lessons (Apple ID 6822433276), was rejected on 11 November under Guideline 5.1.1(v). We replied in App Store Connect the same day, explaining why the information is needed for the app's age rules, and resubmitted the same build. The submission has been "Waiting for Review" since 11 November and our reply has had no answer. An expedited review request was accepted on 17 November. The app has been live on Google Play since 2 November, and teachers and students are waiting for the iOS version. Could someone from App Review look at submission a25aeb0c-7a67-446a-a195-a3694a8e9ede, or tell us if anything more is needed from our side? Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
36
Activity
2h
Eternal waiting for review problem
Hi everyone. I'm developer, who works just with iOS for the last 4 years, and am a part of Apple ecosystem from 2012, work with swift (no cross-platform like unity etc.) During last month I get such a problem - time of waiting for review for my new app is geting longer and longer. This is time chronology: Nov 4, 2026 at 8:55 PM - Waiting for Review Nov 13, 2026 at 8:52 PM - In Review Nov 13, 2026 at 8:52 PM - Rejected (as you can see, there is auto-rejection even with no app review), with autogenerate message, after my reply I still wait for real review Nov 13, 2026 at 9:27 PM - Waiting for Review So, at the moment it's around 2 weeks from the start of waiting/review process (even though Apple tell us that 90% of reviews go withing 48 hours). No answer for all my letters, no reaction for Expredited Review ticket. So, Apple, sorry for such a direct question, but, what's going wrong with all your processes now? P.S.: Dear developers, if you have the same problem, please, try to support this ticket, as we can get more replies, I do hope - we can get Apple attention faster.
Replies
3
Boosts
1
Views
102
Activity
2h
Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6: Publishing separate apps for multiple companies under one or separate developer accounts
Hello everyone, I’m developing a work management app using React Native/Expo for multiple companies. The apps share a common codebase and similar core functionality, but each company has its own app name, logo, bundle ID, and company-specific data. Each company wants a separate app publicly available on the App Store so users can search for and download it. Private distribution through Custom Apps or a single shared app with a company selector would not meet their requirements. I’d like to understand how App Review Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6 apply to these two scenarios: 1. All apps published under one organization’s developer account Our company would develop and publish all client apps under our own Apple Developer Program organization account. Is there a compliant way to support this model? What requirements would each app need to meet? 2. Each app published under the client company’s own developer account Each client company would enroll in the Apple Developer Program and publish its app under its own organization account, while our team handles development and assists with submission. Could these apps still be rejected under Guideline 4.3(a) because they share a codebase and similar functionality? For both scenarios, I’d appreciate clarification on the following: What differences in functionality, content, or business workflows would help establish each app as a distinct product? How does Guideline 4.2.6 apply to this shared-platform model? What supporting documentation should we provide, such as development contracts or letters of authorization? How should we explain the business need for separate apps in App Review Notes? Has anyone successfully implemented a similar model? I’m looking for a compliant, sustainable approach, rather than a workaround to the review guidelines. Thank you for your advice and experience.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
132
Activity
2h
app for a web-based business service covered by 3.1.3(f)?
Hi all, My iOS app has been rejected several times under Guidelines 3.1.1 and 3.1.3(c), and I'd appreciate input from anyone who has dealt with something similar. The app is a free app for booking appointments with local service businesses (salons, barbers, etc.). Customers use it for free and can pay an optional deposit directly to a business for a real-world service. Business owners use the same app to manage their calendar and clients. The paid part: Business owners buy a subscription to our web-based management service only on our website. The app has no In-App Purchase, no pricing, and no button or link to purchase or manage a subscription, inside or outside the app. The only related screen is a read-only "Subscription Status: Active" label. The rejection: The reviewer says the app offers enterprise services sold to organizations that are also available to single users, so In-App Purchase is required under 3.1.3(c). My question: We are not relying on 3.1.3(c). Our understanding is that a free, stand-alone app that gives access to a paid web service, with no purchase flow and no call to action to buy, is covered by 3.1.3(f). Is that reading correct even when the service is also available to solo business owners? I've replied in App Store Connect and filed an appeal with the App Review Board. If anyone has had a similar case resolved, I'd be glad to hear what helped. Thanks!
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
53
Activity
5h
My game stuck "Waiting for review" practically since Oct 23
I've been working on www.riotcontrolgame.com for almost 9 months before submitting it to the App store, in parallel of Steam and Android. From my experience I was sure it will be approved on Apple first - but it's already approved in all other platforms and I'm just waiting for Apple so I can finally announce and release it properly. I don't know what's the hold up, I feel utterly ignored. The game was at first rejected as "4.3 Spam" which I answered in detail for every concern Apple app review raised. It's an original and unique game that was developed across many months, with many testers, and includes an App clip and search videos. This is a legit and unique tower defense game that is no spam no matter how you look at it. I feel ignored and time goes by, weeks upon weeks with 0 response or care from Apple, which is the only place I'm literally paying 100$ a year to be a developer. I'm getting more attention from Android and Steam, and much faster responsiveness compared. I love Apple, and I want to continue releasing apps and games to the App Store. Please, if there's anyone who can run some kind of a total account review and contact me (in any media possible), I will highly appreciate it.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
64
Activity
7h
Account suspended under DPLA 14.8(a) – compliance documents provided over a week ago
My Individual Developer account (Team ID: SU8NVE3Z6C) has been suspended due to an automated compliance check regarding digital assets, citing Sections 14.8(a) and 2.8 of the DPLA. I have a clean 13-year track record on the App Store. On September 23, immediately after receiving the automated notice, I submitted all requested documentary evidence directly to provider_review. I provided my official residence documents and description of my apps. They do not involve custody, exchange, trading, or transmission of digital assets, nor do they violate any applicable laws. It has now been over a week since I submitted the full documentation. My entire portfolio of apps remains removed from the App Store. This prolonged downtime is causing severe ongoing financial loss and severely disrupting the experience for my active subscribers. Could an Apple Community Specialist or a senior support engineer please help escalate this review? I have provided everything asked of me and urgently need my account access restored. Thank you in advance for your assistance.
Replies
9
Boosts
7
Views
1.2k
Activity
8h
Resubmission in Waiting for Review since 1 November
App: Clube de Campo de São Paulo (Apple ID 6827749386), iOS 1.1 (1) Submission ID: b0f93dd1-d7eb-4ced-9390-89522733fdd4 This is a new app. It was rejected on 30 October under guideline 2.5.4. We replied on 1 November with an explanation and a screen recording, and resubmitted the same day. It has been in Waiting for Review since then, and our expedited review request has had no response. We have also opened Developer Support case 30000010412347. Could someone from App Review check whether anything is blocking this submission?
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
117
Activity
8h
First app stuck in "Waiting for Review" since November 7, support case unanswered
Hello, My first app has been in "Waiting for Review" for 10 days without moving, and I would appreciate it if someone from App Review could check whether anything is holding it. App: FindDish (Apple ID 6818187210), iOS Version 1.0, build 261107.1004 Submission ID: 952c8d73-8ddf-478a-98b2-3aefc343c77a Submitted: November 7, 2026, 10:53 UTC Developer Support case: 30000013180228 (opened November 12; so far only the automatic acknowledgement) This is the first submission from a new individual developer account. The submission has not been cancelled or resubmitted. There are no messages in App Store Connect and no information requests. The agreements are accepted, App Privacy is published, and the trader information for the Digital Services Act was submitted on November 7 and still shows as being verified. Is there anything missing on my side, for example the trader verification, that keeps the app from entering review? If something else is needed I will provide it right away. Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
29
Activity
8h
Case ID: 103016369752 - App stuck in Process for Distribution
Hi, my app has beens stuck in Process for Distribution for over 2 weeks. I have tried to contact the developement team which escalated it to the review team but now it has gone silent for over a week. Does anyone know how to contact the correct team to resolve this issue? It is very frustratiing because I cannot even reject the update and restart the review process. It is in limbo. Please help! Case ID: 103016369752
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
17
Activity
9h
Expedited review was approved, but app stuck in Waiting for Review since Nov 13
Hello App Review Team, I’m writing to ask for your help checking my app submission. I submitted my app for review on November 13. It has now been over 96 hours (4 full days). I previously emailed the App Review team to request expedited review, and my expedited review request was formally approved. The reply confirmed my app would be reviewed as soon as possible. However, up to this point, I still see no movement on my app’s review status. The build remains stuck in Waiting for Review with no pending messages or additional requests inside App Store Connect. Based on the current progress, even with the approved expedited review, my app is taking longer than a standard non-expedited submission. I am trying to understand the reason for this. Could you please look into this delay and advise what might be causing it? Please let me know what actions I need to take on my end.submission ID:78b8dd94-fd4c-4951-959b-4fdb57a659d7 I appreciate your support.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
66
Activity
11h
DishNear: Homemade Food — "Waiting for Review" 14 days after resubmission (Apple ID 6795711801)
Our first app, DishNear: Homemade Food (iOS 1.0.0, build 8, Australia only), was rejected on 2 Nov 2026. We answered both points (EULA link and IAP price confirmation) and resubmitted on 3 Nov 2026. It has been Waiting for Review since. We sent status inquiries on 9 Nov (case 30000009951816) and 16 Nov, with no reply. Agreements, tax and banking are all active, and there are no open messages in App Store Connect. Could someone from App Review confirm the submission is queued correctly and whether anything is needed from us? Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
179
Activity
15h
Waiting for Review since Nov 13 after answering Guideline 2.1(b), expedite approved (App ID 6830445332)
Hello App Review team, Our app Nova Owner (Apple ID 6830445332, submission ID b14521ae-ffd5-4612-b96e-adf082ed39f6, version 1.0.0 (3)) has been Waiting for Review since November 13 after we answered a Guideline 2.1(b) business model question. Timeline (UTC): Nov 4: first submission. Nov 5: Guideline 2.1 information request, answered with a screen recording. Nov 12: expedited review approved. Nov 13: Guideline 2.1(b) business model question. We answered all six questions in App Store Connect at 05:56 and resubmitted the same build at 06:01. Our backend logs show a reviewer session from Apple's network on Nov 13, 06:05–06:08, covering every tab of the demo account. There has been no reviewer sign-in or app activity since then, and no new message in App Store Connect. Business model: Nova Owner is a free companion app for homeowners who have an offline property management agreement with our company for physical services at their home. Fees are settled on the owner's monthly statement outside the app. The app sells and unlocks no digital content, subscriptions or features, and has no payment of any kind. We need to launch to our existing clients this month. Could someone please check whether the submission is waiting on anything from us? Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
148
Activity
16h
Is Apple Music artwork allowed in a music discovery app without playback?
Hi Apple Developer Community, I'm developing an iOS app focused on music discovery and social interaction. Users can share songs with people nearby, and I'd like to use the Apple Music API to retrieve song metadata and album artwork. The artwork would appear on map markers, shared song cards, and user music profiles. The app is not primarily a music player, and users would be able to open songs in Apple Music. I'd like to clarify: Is this use of Apple Music metadata and album artwork permitted under the MusicKit / Apple Music API terms, even without in-app music playback? Would displaying artwork in these social discovery contexts require additional licensing or permission? If additional permission is needed, which official Apple team or licensing channel should I contact? I want to ensure the app complies with Apple's terms before release. Thank you for your guidance!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
151
Activity
16h
Unbelievable: 2 App Store rejections, ZERO uses of our app's main feature. What would you do - appeal or resubmit?
I'm genuinely at a loss with Apple's App Review process. Our backend records show that across BOTH reviews, Apple's reviewers did not complete a SINGLE use of our app's core functionality. Not once. ZERO completed generations. For the latest review, our logs confirm Apple successfully logged in, but recorded ZERO generation requests and ZERO credits consumed. This isn't some minor feature. It's the entire foundation of our app. Our app fundamentally changes and becomes personalised as it's used. Without completing that process, you're essentially judging an incomplete product. Submission ID: 6a126514-9bb6-4d91-923c-bf29aacb1b68 Here's why this is so frustrating. We spent months deliberately building an app that offers functionality and a user experience fundamentally different from existing competitors. This wasn't another copycat app - avoiding that was central to its design from day one. We explained these differences extensively in our App Review notes. Yet Apple has rejected us TWICE under Guideline 4.3(b) — Design Spam. We even provided a narrated walkthrough demonstrating exactly what makes our app unique. Our video analytics show ZERO views. So we're being rejected for supposedly lacking originality, despite neither review producing a completed use of our main feature and no recorded views of our demonstration. After both rejections, we've received nothing but generic responses telling us to improve the app, without identifying a single specific problem. How are independent developers supposed to fix something when Apple won't explain what's wrong? We've now filed a formal appeal, which could take a month, with no visible queue position, progress updates or estimated timeframe. Meanwhile, we've already missed multiple planned marketing opportunities, and waiting could mean missing even more. We're not asking for guaranteed approval. We're asking for a fair review of what we've actually built. Has anyone else experienced this? What would you do? Wait for the appeal, hoping the App Review Board properly evaluates the app, even if it takes another month and we miss more deadlines? Withdraw the appeal and resubmit, hoping for a different reviewer, but risking another rejection without proper testing and further warnings against our developer account? I'd genuinely appreciate advice from anyone who's experienced something similar, especially those who've successfully appealed a 4.3(b) rejection. At this point, I genuinely don't know whether this is a reviewer misunderstanding, an automated rejection process, or something else entirely. But how can Apple determine that an app lacks originality when its defining functionality hasn't even been tested?
Replies
18
Boosts
1
Views
998
Activity
17h
App stuck "In Review" for 12 days after resubmission (Case 103001645719)
Hello, Our app has been in "In Review" status since October 25, 2026 — 12 days now, with no messages or requests from App Review. App: Ryla: Photo Looks & Filters (Apple ID 6821447421) Submission ID: bbe1d65e-6429-4c33-9a25-7c2128f6c8a8 Items: version 1.0 (build 10), two auto-renewable subscriptions, a subscription group and three consumable in-app purchases Developer Support case: 103001645719 Timeline: Oct 12: first submission Oct 25: rejected under Guideline 1.1 (screenshots); we replaced the flagged screenshots and previews and resubmitted the same day Oct 25 → today: "In Review", no further updates We have also requested an expedited review and replied to our Developer Support case. Agreements, tax and banking are all active, and there are no unanswered messages in App Store Connect. Could someone from App Review please check whether this submission is stuck? We're happy to provide a demo video, test details or anything else needed right away. Thank you.
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
149
Activity
17h
App Stuck In Review Since October 26, 2026 — No Updates Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello, I'm reaching out regarding an ongoing issue with an iOS application that has been stuck in the "In Review" status since October 26, 2026. As of today, November 13, the application has been in review for 18 days without any updates, rejection notices, requests for additional information, or communication explaining the delay. I've published multiple applications through the App Store before, and while I understand that review times can vary, I've never experienced anything remotely close to this. I've reached out to Apple Developer Support multiple times, sent approximately five emails, and even spent nearly three hours on hold trying to speak with someone who could provide some information. I've also submitted an expedited review request, which unfortunately hasn't resulted in any progress either. I even spoke with a support representative who mentioned that they would try to push the issue forward, but despite all these attempts, I still haven't received any meaningful updates or explanations. This delay has significantly affected my business, and it's incredibly frustrating to have an application sitting in review for this long without knowing what's happening or whether anything is actually being done. I completely understand that certain applications might require additional review time, and I have no issue with that. However, I would at least expect some form of communication, especially after nearly three weeks and multiple attempts to contact support. At this point, I'm genuinely concerned that the application might be stuck in Apple's review system or that something has gone wrong internally. Has anyone experienced a similar situation where an application remained specifically in "In Review" for this long? Is there any way to reach someone directly from the App Review team or escalate this beyond the standard support channels? I've already tried requesting an expedited review without success, so I'm unsure what other options are available. I'd appreciate any guidance or assistance, especially from someone at Apple who might be able to look into this. Thank you.
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
225
Activity
17h
Approved Expedited Review Stuck in "Waiting for Review" for 90+ Hours — App ID 6828609335
App: Drip Rides (App ID 6828609335), version 1.0.13 — a new app submission made on October 30, 2026. It has been in "Waiting for Review" since submission and has never moved to "In Review." An expedited review was requested for a timed launch and approved on Sunday, November 1, but the status has not changed since — over 90 hours in "Waiting for Review" in total. We announced a November 2 launch and have missed it. Developer Support case: 103017689548 App Review inquiry case: 30000003909762 (filed today, November 3) Could someone please check whether the expedited review is properly attached to this submission and escalate it to the App Review team for manual assignment? Thank you. — Eric, Drip Rides
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
182
Activity
17h
App Stuck in Review for Over a Month – Already Published on Google Play with Strong User Interest
Hello Apple App Review Team, I am an independent game developer, and my game has been stuck in the App Review process for approximately one month without a final decision. Submission ID: e1dfbdc4-ed91-4e02-acf5-1de15461d895 My application has been awaiting review for an unusually long period. After several weeks without progress, I canceled the previous submission and submitted it again, hoping to resolve the delay. Unfortunately, the latest submission is still in "Waiting for Review", with no further updates or explanation. I would also like to highlight that my game is already published on Google Play, where it has attracted significant user interest and exceeded 10,000 downloads. Google Play link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.alpsoft.kus The game is actively available to Android users, and I am eager to make it available to iOS users as well. As an independent developer, I have invested considerable time and effort into creating and improving this game. The prolonged review delay is affecting my ability to reach new players and expand to another platform. I fully understand that Apple needs to carefully review applications before publication. However, I would sincerely appreciate assistance in understanding why my submission has remained pending for so long. Could an Apple App Review representative please: Investigate the reason for this unusually long delay. Confirm whether anything is preventing my application from entering active review. Escalate my submission to the appropriate team. Provide an update or guidance on any further steps required. I am not requesting automatic approval or special treatment. I simply hope my game can receive a fair and timely review. Thank you for your time and assistance. I would greatly appreciate any help in resolving this situation. Best regards, Independent Game Developer
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
383
Activity
17h
developer information updating in process for more than 30 days?
hi, I have updated my developer information months ago, it is almost before 30 days, I found that I could not submit any updates or new app to AppStore as it says "Note: Your developer information update is in process.". I know it will take some time, as the document states it is about 1 or 2 weeks, however, it is now more than 30 days passed, it is still in process. I am a little worried about what happened on this process? I want to get contact with the right Apple employee, so that I could know what happened on it. There're some updates and bug fixes I could not wait for more time, so if anyone know how to get it solved, it will be very appreciated!
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
656
Activity
21h